Jake's Restaurant
Inside Jake's Restaurant
Jake's Restaurant sits comfortably in Brookfield as a spot that blends the upscale feel of a steakhouse with the nostalgic charm of a supper club. The atmosphere reflects its Wisconsin roots, featuring decor filled with vintage pieces that give the space a warm, familiar vibe without feeling stuffy. Whether you're dressed casually or dressed up, the setting invites a relaxed yet refined dining experience.
This is a place for those who appreciate classic American steakhouse fare with a few thoughtful twists. The menu focuses on quality cuts, like Angus boneless ribeyes and a trio of filet medallions, alongside other hearty options such as braised short ribs, roasted duck, and a well-rated burger. Sides are traditional but elevated — the double baked potato with cheddar and bacon is a solid choice, as are the creamed spinach and the wild rice pilaf. Locals seem to enjoy complementing their mains with starters like truffled deviled eggs or Wisconsin cheese curds, which have become somewhat of a favorite here.
Jake’s appeals especially to couples and small groups looking for a comfortable place to mark special occasions or enjoy a deliberate night out. Service tends to be attentive, contributing to a leisurely pace where diners can savor both their meal and the company. The bar area offers a chance to start or end the evening, though it might feel less lively than the dining room on busy nights.
Expect to find the kitchen focusing on consistent, well-prepared dishes rather than bold experimentation. Most steaks come cooked just right, and desserts like creme brûlée or a grasshopper cocktail provide a familiar, satisfying finish. While the menu doesn’t include mashed potatoes, the variety of sides available still covers traditional preferences.
In terms of timing, weeknights and weekends both work well, but reserving a table is recommended given the place’s steady local following. Whether it’s a birthday, anniversary, or simply a night to treat yourself, Jake’s offers a dependable balance of good food, welcoming service, and a classic Wisconsin supper club atmosphere that keeps people coming back.
Highlights & Local Essentials
Find It on the Map
What Locals & Travelers Say
190 Reviews
01 Jan 2026
30 Nov 2025
13 Nov 2025
07 Nov 2025
31 Oct 2025
17 Oct 2025
07 Oct 2025
28 Sep 2025
More Local Spots to Explore
Daily Coffee Bertam
Donut Wheel
Restaurante Lebeche
Cafe 4
Garcia's Mexican Food To Go
Join the Jake's Restaurant Newsletter
Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.